1. The Flaw of Static (Fixed) Budgets
A Fixed Budget is built around a single, preset production volume (e.g., planning costs based on making exactly 10,000 units). At the end of the year, comparing actual results against a fixed budget is highly misleading if the actual volume differed from the plan. If the factory actually made 12,000 units, variable costs will naturally look overspent, making it impossible to judge true cost efficiency.
Â
2. The Architecture of a Flexible Budget
A Flexible Budget is a dynamic model that recalculates budgeted costs for any activity level. It splits costs into fixed and variable components, allowing managers to see what costs should have been for the volume actually achieved.Â
Â
3. Step-by-Step Flexibility Adjustments
To create a flexible budget for comparison, multiply original variable costs per unit by the actual volume achieved, while keeping fixed costs constant:
Flexible Cost Target = (fixed costs that stay the same) + (variable cost per unit × the actual number of units you produced).
Variance Performance Comparison
Cost Item Static Budget (10k units) Actual Costs (12k units) Flexible Budget (12k units) True Efficiency Variance
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Materials (Var) $50,000 $58,000 $60,000 $2,000 (Favorable)
Factory Rent (Fix) 20,000 20,000 20,000 0
Analysis: Compared against the static budget, materials look overspent by $8,000. However, when compared against a flexible budget adjusted for the actual volume of 12,000 units, the team was actually $2,000 under budget, proving the operation was highly efficient.
Â