1. Nature of the Special Order Dilemma
A special order occurs when a one-time customer requests a large batch of products at a price significantly lower than the standard market rate. These orders are often placed by export clients or private-label brands.
2. Minimum Acceptable Pricing Rules
If a factory has idle capacity (unused machinery and labor), the minimum acceptable price for a special order is the total incremental cost of producing that order. Fixed overheads are ignored because they are already covered by normal daily operations.
Minimum special-order price = incremental variable cost per unit + any direct special setup expenses (if applicable).
3. Strategic and Qualitative Risk Filters
Accepting a low-priced special order based purely on marginal costs carries significant risks that managers must evaluate:
  • Market Cannibalization: Regular customers might discover the lower price and demand the same discount, destroying normal retail margins.
  • Capacity Locking: If the company locks up its machinery with a low-margin special order, it may be forced to turn down high-margin regular orders if demand unexpectedly returns.
  • Brand Dilution: Selling premium goods under a discount structure can damage long-term brand value.

 
PreviousNext