Learning Outcomes

By the end of this lesson, learners should be able to:

  • Explain the Blue Ocean Strategy framework and the concept of value innovation.

  • Distinguish between red ocean and blue ocean strategic approaches.

  • Apply the Eliminate-Reduce-Raise-Create (ERRC) Grid to reconstruct market boundaries.

  • Analyze strategies for identifying non-customers and unlocking new demand.

  • Develop market-creation strategies for sustainable growth and competitive advantage.

Introduction

Most companies compete in search of sustained profitable growth but end up in ‘red oceans’ of rivalry and shrinking profits . As competition intensifies, products become commoditized, resulting in shrinking profits and growth . The fundamental challenge facing business leaders today is how to escape crowded markets and create uncontested spaces where competition becomes irrelevant. This is precisely the challenge that Blue Ocean Strategy addresses.

Blue Ocean Strategy, developed by Professors W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne of INSEAD, provides a systematic framework for creating new market spaces rather than competing in existing ones . The approach is built on the concept of value innovation—the simultaneous pursuit of differentiation and low cost—which makes competitors irrelevant by creating a leap in value for both the firm and its customers .

What makes Blue Ocean Strategy particularly powerful is that it is not simply about “thinking outside the box.” It is a systematic framework with practical tools that enable organizations to identify non-customers—people currently ignored by the industry—and solve their specific pain points, thereby creating entirely new markets rather than competing over existing ones . This lesson provides a comprehensive exploration of Blue Ocean Strategy and market-creating innovation, examining the core concepts, analytical tools, and practical applications that enable organizations to break away from competition and achieve sustainable growth.

1. Red Ocean versus Blue Ocean Strategy

The distinction between red ocean and blue ocean strategies is fundamental to understanding market-creating innovation. These two approaches represent fundamentally different ways of thinking about competition and growth.

The Red Ocean: Competing in Existing Markets

Red oceans represent all the industries in existence today—the known market space where industry boundaries are defined, competitive rules are well understood, and companies compete to capture a greater share of existing demand . In red oceans, the intense competition turns the water bloody, hence the name. Products become commoditized, companies fight for the same customers, and profit margins shrink as competition intensifies .

Red ocean strategy is characterized by:

  • Competing in existing market spaces: Organizations fight for market share in established industries.

  • Defeating the competition: Success is defined by outperforming rivals.

  • Exploiting existing demand: Companies focus on capturing a larger share of the current market.

  • Making the value-cost trade-off: Companies choose between differentiation (higher cost) or low cost (lower perceived value).

In red oceans, companies typically respond to competitive pressures by trying to improve incrementally—offering slightly better products, slightly lower prices, or slightly better service. The result is often a race to the bottom where no one wins.

The Blue Ocean: Creating Uncontested Market Space

Blue oceans represent all the industries not in existence today—the unknown market space where demand is created rather than fought over . In blue oceans, competition is irrelevant because the rules of the game are waiting to be set . The term “blue ocean” is metaphorical for the vast, deep, and unexploited market space of new demand.

Blue ocean strategy is characterized by:

  • Creating new market spaces: Organizations make competition irrelevant by creating new demand.

  • Making the competition irrelevant: Success is defined by creating new markets rather than fighting in existing ones.

  • Creating and capturing new demand: Companies unlock new customers who were previously non-customers.

  • Breaking the value-cost trade-off: Organizations simultaneously pursue differentiation and low cost—the essence of value innovation.

Blue ocean strategy challenges the presumptions stated by traditional strategy—that market structures and competitive conditions are fixed and cannot be changed by the efforts of a company . Instead, Blue Ocean Strategy demonstrates that companies can reconstruct industry boundaries and create new market space.

2. Value Innovation: The Cornerstone of Blue Ocean Strategy

Value innovation is the cornerstone of Blue Ocean Strategy. It is based on the simultaneous pursuit of differentiation and low cost, creating a leap in value for both buyers and the company itself . As one executive program describes it, value innovation is “the simultaneous pursuit of differentiation and low cost,” enabling organizations to move beyond competition .

The Concept of Value Innovation

The logic behind value innovation challenges the traditional assumption that companies must choose between value (differentiation) and cost (efficiency). Traditional strategy suggests that value creation (higher cost) and cost reduction (lower perceived value) are trade-offs. Value innovation breaks this trade-off by focusing on what customers value and eliminating, reducing, raising, and creating factors to deliver unprecedented value at lower cost.

Value innovation differs from technology innovation. While technology innovation involves creating useful technology, value innovation involves creating a business strategy . The distinction is critical: many inventors gained little from their inventions because they focused on technology rather than value . In contrast, companies like Starbucks and Curves achieved market dominance through value innovation—redefining the traditional coffee place and challenging the highly competitive fitness industry by simultaneously offering higher value and lower cost .

The Market Dynamics of Value Innovation

Kim and Mauborgne identify three characteristics of companies that achieve market dominance through value innovation :

1. They shift the demand curve out: By offering a leap in value, they expand demand and attract new customers who were previously non-customers . This shifts the demand curve from D1 to D2, creating new demand rather than merely capturing existing demand.

2. They set a strategic price: They set a price that people not only want to pay but can also afford, capturing the mass of target buyers in the expanded market . This strategic pricing increases the quantity sold and builds strong brand recognition.

3. They lower the long-run average cost curve: Through target costing and efficiency focus, they simultaneously reduce costs to expand profitability and discourage free-riding imitation . This enables the company to earn a leap in profit and growth.

The result is a win-win dynamic where companies earn dominant positions while buyers become winners too. The consumer surplus increases, and society benefits from improved efficiency . This contrasts with traditional monopolistic practices, which set high prices, limit consumption, and often fail to focus on efficiency, creating a deadweight loss in the economy .

Types of Market-Creating Strategy

Kim and Mauborgne discuss three ways of pursuing market-creating strategy :

1. Offering a breakthrough solution for an existing industry problem: This approach tends to be closer to disruptive creation. An example would be finding a better way to store and replay sound recordings, fundamentally improving the value proposition for existing customers.

2. Redefining and solving an existing industry problem: This approach lies in between and allows an organization to replace assumptions and reconstruct industry boundaries in new ways . The organization reframes the problem in a way that makes existing competitors irrelevant.

3. Identifying and solving a brand-new problem: This is non-disruptive creation, unlocking new markets beyond existing industry boundaries . The organization creates demand where none existed before.

3. The Six Paths Framework: Reconstructing Market Boundaries

The Six Paths Framework provides a systematic approach for reconstructing market boundaries and identifying blue ocean opportunities. It helps organizations look beyond existing industry boundaries to find new market spaces.

The Six Paths

The Six Paths Framework guides organizations to look across:

1. Alternative Industries: Looking across industries that serve the same purpose or solve the same problem. For example, Southwest Airlines looked across airlines and car travel to create a new value proposition for short-haul travel.

2. Strategic Groups: Looking across strategic groups within the same industry. For example, Curves looked across large fitness chains and small fitness studios to create a new approach targeting women who felt intimidated by traditional gyms.

3. Buyer Groups: Looking across the chain of buyers, including purchasers, users, and influencers. For example, pharmaceutical companies might target users (patients) rather than purchasers (doctors) to create new demand.

4. Complementary Product and Service Offerings: Looking across complementary products and services to identify opportunities. For example, bookstores might add cafes, or software companies might add training and consulting.

5. Functional-Emotional Appeal: Looking across the functional-emotional orientation of the industry. For example, the fashion industry is emotionally oriented, but companies might introduce functional appeal through durability and practicality.

6. Time: Looking across the time dimension, considering emerging trends and how they might reshape the industry.

Field Exploration and Non-Customer Analysis

The Six Paths Framework is not just an intellectual exercise—it requires field exploration and observing non-customers. The insight gained from the Six Paths is translated into concrete strategic options .

Non-customers are people currently ignored by the entire industry . By solving their specific pain points, organizations can create entirely new markets rather than competing over existing ones. There are typically three tiers of non-customers:

  • First Tier: Customers who are on the boundary of the industry and would defect with the slightest push.

  • Second Tier: Customers who deliberately choose not to use the industry’s offerings because they don’t meet their needs.

  • Third Tier: Customers who have never considered the industry’s offerings because they are in completely different markets.

By understanding why these non-customers do not use the industry’s offerings and what they actually need, organizations can identify blue ocean opportunities.

4. The Strategy Canvas and ERRC Grid

The Strategy Canvas and the Eliminate-Reduce-Raise-Create (ERRC) Grid are the two core diagnostic tools of Blue Ocean Strategy. They help organizations translate insights into actionable strategies.

The Strategy Canvas

The Strategy Canvas is a diagnostic and action framework for creating blue oceans. It captures the current state of play in the known market space and visually depicts what competitors offer, what customers currently receive, and where the organization should focus its strategic efforts.

The Strategy Canvas has two axes:

  • The horizontal axis captures the range of factors the industry competes on

  • The vertical axis captures the offering level that buyers receive across all these key factors

A strong strategy canvas has three characteristics:

  1. It clearly shows the value curve that differentiates the organization from competitors

  2. It demonstrates that the organization’s value curve offers a leap in value

  3. It is easy to communicate and understand

The Four Actions Framework

The Four Actions Framework provides a systematic approach for creating a new value curve. It asks four key questions:

  • Which factors should be ELIMINATED that the industry has long competed on?

  • Which factors should be REDUCED well below the industry’s standard?

  • Which factors should be RAISED well above the industry’s standard?

  • Which factors should be CREATED that the industry has never offered?

Eliminating and reducing provides insights into how to lower the cost structure, while raising and creating drives a leap in buyer value . The four questions challenge the industry’s strategic logic and force organizations to consider entirely new alternatives.

The ERRC Grid

The Eliminate-Reduce-Raise-Create Grid is a supplementary analytic tool that translates the insights gained from the Six Paths Framework and field exploration into concrete and actionable strategic options . It is built on the four key questions from the Four Actions Framework.

The ERRC Grid provides a framework for developing blue ocean strategic options that break away from competition and pursue both differentiation and low cost . The grid pushes organizations to:

  • Eliminate: Remove factors that have marginal effects on performance but consume resources.

  • Reduce: Scale back factors that provide limited value to customers.

  • Raise: Enhance factors that customers value highly.

  • Create: Introduce entirely new factors that customers have never experienced.

A study on value innovation and blue ocean strategy applying the ERRC Grid highlights how companies can use the framework to challenge existing industry assumptions and create new value propositions . By applying the grid systematically, organizations can identify strategic opportunities that might otherwise remain hidden .

5. Application and Implementation

Blue Ocean Strategy is not just a theoretical framework—it requires disciplined application and execution. The Practitioner Program developed by Kim and Mauborgne provides a structured approach for translating blue ocean concepts into actionable strategies .

The Blue Ocean Process

The process of creating a blue ocean strategy typically involves :

Phase 1: Get Started: Building the right team and creating the strategic context for blue ocean thinking. This involves identifying the strategic challenge and establishing the transformation team.

Phase 2: Understand Where You Are Now: Mapping the current strategic landscape using the Strategy Canvas. This involves understanding the current state of competition and identifying the factors that shape the industry.

Phase 3: Imagine Where You Could Be: Using the Six Paths Framework to explore blue ocean opportunities. This involves looking across alternative industries, strategic groups, buyer groups, and other paths to identify new possibilities.

Phase 4: Develop Your Blue Ocean Strategy: Applying the ERRC Grid to create a new value curve. This involves determining what to eliminate, reduce, raise, and create.

Phase 5: Communicate and Execute: Building buy-in and implementing the blue ocean strategy. This involves developing the strategic price, addressing the people proposition, and ensuring organizational alignment.

Sustaining Blue Ocean Success

Once a blue ocean is created, competitors will eventually try to imitate it. Sustaining blue ocean success requires:

  • Building brand recognition: Creating strong brand loyalty that makes imitation more difficult.

  • Creating barriers to imitation: Developing proprietary capabilities, systems, or relationships that competitors cannot easily replicate.

  • Continuous innovation: Continuing to innovate and evolve the value proposition to stay ahead of imitators.

  • Expanding the blue ocean: Continuously exploring new customer segments and opportunities.

The Blue Ocean Mindset

The benefits of Blue Ocean Strategy extend beyond individual strategies to create a lasting mindset shift. The process helps organizations and individuals :

  • Adopt a blue ocean perspective: Expanding horizons and shifting understanding of where opportunity resides.

  • Learn to define problems differently: Reframing challenges to create game-changing and scalable new growth opportunities.

  • Develop a systematic approach: Applying a proven process and practical tools to create clear, compelling strategies.

  • Build strategic muscle: Developing the capability to continuously identify and pursue blue ocean opportunities.

6. Case Studies in Blue Ocean Strategy

Real-world examples illustrate the power of blue ocean strategy across industries.

Zappos: Value Innovation in E-Commerce

When Zappos started in 1999, it could have easily become one of many online retailers. Instead, the company focused on offering a leap in value by combining the best of a traditional shoe store with the best of an online retailer . In traditional brick-and-mortar shoe stores, one out of three sales was lost due to the unavailability of the right size. Zappos offered a large selection and free shipping both ways, eliminating the risk for customers and dramatically increasing their options .

Zappos eliminated the pain of limited selection and the risk of buying shoes online. It raised the standard of customer service with a generous return policy and free shipping. And it created the experience of trying shoes at home with a large inventory and easy return process. By making competition irrelevant, Zappos achieved market dominance in an industry where many had failed.

Cirque du Soleil: Reconstructing Market Boundaries

Cirque du Soleil created a blue ocean by reconstructing the boundaries between circus and theatre. Instead of competing with traditional circuses on animal acts and star performers, Cirque du Soleil eliminated animals and star performers. It reduced the importance of the “show” element while raising artistic and theatrical elements. And it created an entirely new experience by combining the best of both forms. The result was a new entertainment category that attracted non-customers who never attended traditional circuses.

Nintendo Wii: Targeting Non-Customers

Nintendo created a blue ocean in the video game industry by targeting non-customers rather than competing directly with Sony and Microsoft. The video game industry had become focused on hardcore gamers with increasingly complex and expensive games. Nintendo raised the fun and accessibility elements while eliminating many of the complex features that made games difficult for non-gamers. The result was a new market space that attracted millions of casual and first-time gamers.

Key Takeaways

  • Blue Ocean Strategy provides a systematic framework for creating new market spaces where competition becomes irrelevant, based on the simultaneous pursuit of differentiation and low cost .

  • The distinction between red ocean strategy (competing in existing markets) and blue ocean strategy (creating new markets) reflects fundamentally different approaches to business growth and value creation .

  • Value innovation—the cornerstone of Blue Ocean Strategy—breaks the value-cost trade-off by creating a leap in value for buyers while simultaneously reducing costs .

  • The Six Paths Framework guides organizations to reconstruct market boundaries by looking across alternative industries, strategic groups, buyer groups, complementary offerings, functional-emotional appeal, and time .

  • The ERRC Grid translates insights into concrete strategic actions by identifying factors to eliminate, reduce, raise, and create .

  • Successful blue ocean strategies shift the demand curve out, set a strategic price to capture mass buyers, and lower the cost curve to expand profitability .

  • The Blue Ocean Strategy process provides a systematic approach from understanding the current state to creating and implementing blue ocean strategies .

PreviousNext